ROI on automating the Payroll Function

By: Tushar Bhatia
Date: January 6th, 2010
Posted in: Compensation Planning, HR Best Practices, HR Technology, Payroll | 51 Comments »

It is difficult to anticipate the benefits of taking your payroll online. This was a challenge faced by one of our recent customers where the HR department found it challenging to estimate the ROI derived from implementation of an integrated Payroll software. Manual Payroll System

This article describes some of the benefits analyzed and presented to the senior management such that critical purchase dollars were allocated for the procurement.

The exercise which started as a small initiative actually helped me dive deeper into how a CFO or CEO perceive their human resources department and what are their expectations from an HR platform.

What I will share here is a small part of the study in how organizations are managing their human capital assets and the challenges being faced versus what are the best practices. In this, I will share what are the different metrics and how can organizations save costs in this critical area.

Elements of ROI

To determine the ROI, we had to first understand how the payroll process works in a manual environment. Our interactions revealed that there are three distinct steps in the successful processing of a payroll which are:

1. Data gathering
2. Processing
3. Disbursement and Reporting

For each of these steps above, there are multiple sub-processes which may take substantial effort and time.

To understand the complexities involved in payroll processing and gaining deeper insights into challenges being faced, we further analyzed many other companies across multiple industry verticals, different employee types (blue collared, white collared, management) and found a median effort for each of the sub-processes. Some of these sub-processes on which we could identify the metrics are:

1. General

a. Number of FTE (Full Time Employees) required

2. Data Gathering

a. Number of time records processed in one year
b. Number of Employee Validation Errors seen during the year for time records which will require corrections and authorizations at multiple employee levels.
c. Time for adding a new employee to the system with salary structures and all other required data
d. Time for removing a terminated employee from the payroll system.

3. Processing of Payroll

a. Number of payroll transactions processed
b. Cycle time for audit of payroll prior to disbursement
c. Number of manual checks disbursed.

4.Disbursement and Reporting

a. Number of payroll related queries
b. No of payment errors
c. Cycle time to process a payroll error
d. Time for creation of reports which are submitted on a monthly, quarterly, half-yearly and annually per employee

Once these metrics were identified, we studied the impact of these metrics in manual processing vs processing using web-based, integrated software such as EmpXtrack.

The example below refers to the results for a mid-sized organization with approximately 1,000 employees across multiple locations. The results are the total time spent in one year for processing monthly payrolls.

Process Manual Payroll Best Practices
Number of FTE for managing the payroll process 3.48 employees 0.57 employees
Number of time records processed manually 43,500 5,200
Number of Employee Validation Errors seen during the year for time records 350 4
Time for removing a terminated employee from the payroll system. 3.5 days 1.5 hours
Number of payroll transactions processed 18,500 16,500
Number of payroll related queries 982 177
Number of manual checks disbursed. 50 or more 12 or lesser
No of payment errors 56 7
Cycle time to process a payroll error 7.5 hours 0.3 hour
Cycle time for audit of payroll prior to disbursement 230 hours 60 hours
Time for creation of reports which are submitted on a monthly, quarterly, half-yearly and annually per employee 1050 hours 75 hours
Cost for Processing Payroll USD 190,750 USD 27,550

The analysis of the above data gave an unimaginable saving of costs to the tune of $150,000 per yearwhich is much higher than the cost of acquisition of a software such as EmpXtrack.

The following image graphically illustrates the impact of some of the parameters in the chart above:

Payroll Automation Benefits

We further analyzed the intangible benefits (some of which had cost implications as well) of using our web-based software. Some of these are:

1. No need to print payslips. Employees can view their payslips online and these are emailed automatically as well for their records.
2. Minimum payroll related queries post processing. Allows the accounts/HR to complete many more important tasks.
3. Minimum impact when salaries change. Update at a single place is reflected automatically. This avoids reprocessing of payroll.
4. Low impact when new employees are added. For example – for a multi-locational organization with distributed hiring, it becomes difficult to process payroll for new employees.
5. Minimum impact when employees quit.
6. Integration with time reporting systems saves costly mistakes and reprocessing time.
7. Automatic updates to tax tables when the need arises.
8. Archiving of Payroll data for statistical analysis in respect of different employee types.

To analyze the ROI for your company, please fill in the attached form and contact us. We will be happy to analyze your processes, at no obligations, and suggest areas where improvements can be carried out.


I want to automate Payroll

  1. (required)
  2. Company

    (valid email required)

  3. (required)


51 Responses to “ROI on automating the Payroll Function”

  1. Twitter Trackbacks for Benefits of Payroll Software Automation using EmpXtrack | Talent Junction – An HR Blog [empxtrack.com] on Topsy.com Says:

    [...] Benefits of Payroll Software Automation using EmpXtrack | Talent Junction – An HR Blog empxtrack.com/blog/01/benefits-of-payroll-software-automation – view page – cached Benefits of automation of Payroll Systems: This analysis shows how to save costs to the tune of $150,000 per year using software such as EmpXtrack. [...]

  2. Outsourcing Tech Support Says:

    This is a pertinent post. A fabulous article with an amazing level of detail! I truly appreciate your effort to inform us. Many thanks for sharing this. Glad I came across this site.

    - Jaime

  3. ROI on automating the Payroll Function : HR india Says:

    [...] Read further on my blog Talent Junction [...]

  4. wedding singer Says:

    Hi, good day. Wonderful post. You have gained a new subscriber. Pleasee continue this great work and I look forward to more of your great blog posts.

  5. Carnival of HR Mardi Gras Edition Says:

    [...] Payroll is a topic not always covered in our sexy HR blogs but Tusha Bhatia over at the Talent Junction blog has a great post covering ROI on automating the Payroll Function. [...]

  6. human resource management Says:

    Technology has catch up on payroll processing making it systematic and cost – effective.

  7. HR Software solutions Says:

    Solid article well covered.

  8. Kurt Piermarini Says:

    Hi, this is one excellent article! Thanx for posting this. I was hunting for a site that has this kind of info. I just like very much farmville! Lucky I found this one! I’ll be frequenting here again for sure! ftw

  9. Sylvie Kekiwi Says:

    Your blog looks nice, however it would be better if you can use lighter colors as well as a professional design. This will ensure that a lot more readers come to check it out.Informative post by the way!

  10. Tutorial Wordpress Says:

    Very well written post, do you have an rss feed I can subscribe to?

  11. Tushar Bhatia Says:

    Thank you! You can find the RSS feed to the blog at http://www.empxtrack.com/blog/feed/ which is also available at the right section under the Meta block (Entries RSS)

    Hope that works.
    Tushar

  12. Figuring this stuff can be super painstaking, thanks for typing this post to clear up some confusion.

  13. Excellent info! I’ve been looking for something like this for a while now. Thanks!

  14. Twitter Trackbacks for Benefits of Payroll Software Automation using EmpXtrack | Talent Junction – An HR Blog [empxtrack.com] on Topsy.com Says:

    [...] Benefits of Payroll Software Automation using EmpXtrack | Talent Junction – An HR Blog http://www.empxtrack.com/blog/01/benefits-of-payroll-software-automation – view page – cached Benefits of automation of Payroll Systems: This analysis shows how to save costs to the tune of $150,000 per year using software such as EmpXtrack. Tweets about this link Topsy.Data.Twitter.User['hr_sw'] = {“photo”:”http://s.twimg.com/a/1274144130/images/default_profile_3_normal.png”,”url”:”http://twitter.com/hr_sw”,”nick”:”hr_sw”}; hr_sw: “ROI on the automation of Payroll Software @ http://www.empxtrack.com/blog/01/benefits-of-payroll-software-automation/ ” 17 minutes ago view tweet retweet Topsy.Data.Twitter.User['saiguntech'] = {“photo”:”http://s.twimg.com/a/1274144130/images/default_profile_1_normal.png”,”url”:”http://twitter.com/saiguntech”,”nick”:”saiguntech”}; saiguntech: “ROI on the automation of Payroll Software @ http://www.empxtrack.com/blog/01/benefits-of-payroll-software-automation/ ” 17 minutes ago view tweet retweet Topsy.Data.Twitter.User['tushar_bhatia'] = {“photo”:”http://a3.twimg.com/profile_images/918526401/tushar-bhatia1_normal.jpg”,”url”:”http://twitter.com/tushar_bhatia”,”nick”:”tushar_bhatia”}; tushar_bhatia: “ROI on the automation of Payroll Software @ http://www.empxtrack.com/blog/01/benefits-of-payroll-software-automation/ ” 17 minutes ago view tweet retweet Topsy.Data.Twitter.User['empxtrack'] = {“photo”:”http://a3.twimg.com/profile_images/849809973/EmpXtrack_Logo_100×100px_normal.jpg”,”url”:”http://twitter.com/empxtrack”,”nick”:”empxtrack”}; empxtrack: “ROI on the automation of Payroll Software @ http://www.empxtrack.com/blog/01/benefits-of-payroll-software-automation/ ” 17 minutes ago view tweet retweet Topsy.Data.Twitter.User['saiguntech'] = {“photo”:”http://s.twimg.com/a/1274144130/images/default_profile_1_normal.png”,”url”:”http://twitter.com/saiguntech”,”nick”:”saiguntech”}; saiguntech: “ROI on automating the Payroll Function: Read great insights on http://www.empxtrack.com/blog/01/benefits-of-payroll-software-automation/ ” 2 days ago view tweet retweet Topsy.Data.Twitter.User['tushar_bhatia'] = {“photo”:”http://a3.twimg.com/profile_images/918526401/tushar-bhatia1_normal.jpg”,”url”:”http://twitter.com/tushar_bhatia”,”nick”:”tushar_bhatia”}; tushar_bhatia: “ROI on automating the Payroll Function. Read @ http://www.empxtrack.com/blog/01/benefits-of-payroll-software-automation/ ” 2 days ago view tweet retweet Topsy.Data.Twitter.User['hr_sw'] = {“photo”:”http://s.twimg.com/a/1274144130/images/default_profile_3_normal.png”,”url”:”http://twitter.com/hr_sw”,”nick”:”hr_sw”}; hr_sw: “RT @empxtrack: Payroll Automation Software can save upto $150,000 http://empxtrack.com/blog/01/benefits-of-payroll-software-automation/ !!! ” 3 days ago view tweet retweet Filter tweets [...]

  15. randy roedl Says:

    I found your blog on google and read a few of your other posts. I just added you to my Google News Reader. Keep up the good work Look forward to reading more from you in the future.

  16. Kristopher Cabble Says:

    Totally digg your website thanks a lot for the info

  17. Jermaine Kubic Says:

    Hey could I use some of the insight here in this entry if I reference you with a link back to your site?

  18. Wholesale sunglasses Says:

    Story, i enjoyed sharing this.

  19. Prince Smida Says:

    thankyou lots, I must comment that your website is amazing!

  20. Christian Louboutin Shoes Says:

    i have enjoyed reading thank for sharing your story Greeting.

  21. The info you have here was extremely useful, thanks for opening my eyes to some other alternatives.

  22. Plus Payroll Software Says:

    The priority of any payroll accounting program is to reduce the pay preparation time. Two precious words for any effective payroll accounting software are quickness and accuracy.

  23. blogovod.com Says:

    The {article|info} you {have|got} here was {very|extremely|real} {useful|helpful}, thanks for opening my {mind|eyes} to some other {alternatives|options}….

    Payroll processing can be confusing and hard to do if you aren’t a pro, often it wouldn’t hurt debating some other options….

  24. physical therapist Says:

    Great site. A lot of useful information here. I’m sending it to some friends!

  25. You gave great points here. I did some research on the subject and have found nearly all people agree with your blog.

  26. Susan Credi Says:

    This page is very helpful for me to choose the viable product.

  27. Cheap Insurance Quotes Says:

    You pointed some nice topic. These tips are very helpful.

  28. Roi On Automating The Payroll Function « MarkoWare.com Says:

    [...] Read this further on my blog Talent Junction [...]

  29. Good brief and this mail helped me alot in my college assignement. Thanks you for your information.

  30. Roi On Automating The Payroll Function « Marko.us Says:

    [...] Read this further on my blog Talent Junction [...]

  31. Johnie Devens Says:

    Wow..very good…Nice blog and well updated…

  32. Howard Cosca Says:

    I really enjoyed this post. I can tell you put in a great deal of effort and time into this post. I will be back to read more as you post more!

  33. phentermine 37.5 no prescription needed Says:

    Fantastic!

  34. Career Outlook Says:

    Very informative post, thanks for the share.

  35. Natalia Payroll Says:

    Payroll software will actually make things easier for everyone. It will also help in keeping everything in track unlike the traditional process wherein papers are stacked everywhere. However, I would still prefer to have everything backed up, manually though. In case of some technical gliche.

  36. SoftwarePayroll Says:

    he automation also has helped speed payroll and accounts payable … In 2002, HealthFirst added Web-based functionality to all its ERP applications. … and automating its supply chain and purchasing processes, Bonham estimates. …

  37. SoftwarePayroll Says:

    thanku its a useful article

  38. Payroll Software Says:

    Its really very good post.We enjoyed it lost.
    ________
    Helen.

  39. payroll software+blogs Says:

    Nice site. I am getting lots of informaton about ROI & payroll function.

    ________
    geeta

  40. payroll software Says:

    Thank you payroll software is a nice blog. A very useful information in blog.

    __________
    Kim

  41. Nice site. I am getting lots of informaton about ROI & payroll function.
    ——————-
    SSSSS

  42. Payroll software Says:

    Thank u very much…….You had pointed out a good topic……..
    ———————-
    kiran………

  43. Work Routine Says:

    This site really helped me It Is good one I have gained the wanted information.
    ——————
    Chinna

  44. payroll software Says:

    Thank u for giving an nice information. Its an useful for all.
    ————————
    sweety

  45. HR software Says:

    Thanks for the giving useful information,This blog importance,scope,were elaborated.
    _____________
    Steven

  46. OnlinePhilippinePayrollSystem Says:

    This is why i recommend a payroll system to every business who wanted their status to burst. In just obtaining a single software, you could compute in just a second the most important aspect of your business. So why wait? :)

  47. its very good site for providing payroll information

  48. TechFan.org » Patriot PAY Payroll Software Gives Rhode Island Employers New Option Says:

    [...] servicing Connecticut, contact Patriot Software, Inc., at (877) 968-7147, or visit our Press Page.Canton, OH (PRWEB) September 30, 2011 Employers in Rhode Island have a new option for payroll — Pat…including Connecticut and Maine.Anytime, Anywhere Access to PayrollUnlike traditional off-the-shelf [...]

  49. Fortium Payroll Says:

    Great post! Thanks for sharing.

  50. I discovered your blog web site on google and verify a few of your early posts. Proceed to maintain up the excellent operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking forward to studying extra from you afterward!?

  51. Diann Lobner Says:

    Thank you very much for posting this good content! I am looking forward to checking out more!

Post a Comment